Monday, July 30, 2012

Controversial Olympic rule forces Olympic favorite out of all-around


This blog post is probably overdue since what I am about to vent about happened last night U.S. time and even earlier London time, but I did not have time to write it at midnight last night.

For those of us that have been avoiding Twitter with tweets regarding the Olympics and any kind of Olympic news online at all costs so that we can experience the races, scores and relays without knowing the winner this blog post is for you! For those that check the Olympic news before actually watching the event, well, this post in the online world is about a day and a half overdue.

One of my favorite sports to watch during the Olympic games is definitely women’s gymnastics. It may be because of their amazing power, strength and agility that they make appear so graceful or because whenever I think of the greatest Olympic moments the majority that come to mind are gymnastics. (Of course I’m being biased, but there are a lot of them!)

It also may be because we always crush every other country in this sport and this year is no different. The United States has by far the greatest gymnastics talent in the world, but unfortunately due to a rule configured in 2003 by the Federation Internacional de Gymastique only two athletes from each country are allowed to advance to the all-around. This rule makes no sense to me, but it has been in place for years even before the current U.S. women’s Olympic team were competing. However, this year, like many years before, the top 24 gymnasts in the world will not be competing because they were beaten out by their own teammates.


If you were actually watching the U.S. women’s gymnastic team last night, and not just following the updates on Twitter, it was absolutely heartbreaking to watch. As the arena erupted in cheers for Aly Raisman, fellow U.S. teammate, Jordyn Wieber broke down into sobs covering her face as a role model, best friend, roommate and fellow teammate crushed her Olympic dream. Reining world champion and Olympic favorite, Jordyn Wieber lost her opportunity at the women’s all-around final, one of the showcase events at the Olympics. Instead, she will compete in the team finals on Tuesday.

Jordyn Wieber is arguably THE best gymnast in the world and I think last night she was judged with extremely harsh standards. Of course, I will not argue that I know gymnastics better than an Olympic judge, but I will argue that I think too many points were deducted. Yes, Weiber had slip ups last night but not so drastic that should have cost her the all-around. She killed the vault, wobbled slightly on the beam, did decent on the uneven bars, (keep in mind that IS her worst event so although decent is definitely not a word to be used for the Olympics, I think it can be used in this case) and barely stepped out of bounds on her floor exercise. These are ALL of the mistakes that cost her that all-around spot, but I think far too many points were deducted for such minor mistakes.

I think it is a huge disappointment not only for Weiber, but also the U.S. and the world to not have the opportunity to watch such an amazing athlete and gymnast compete in the all-around.

Of course, don’t’ get me wrong; I am extremely excited to watch Gabby Douglas and Aly Raisman compete. I am just disappointed that I will not be able to watch all three amazing gymnasts in the all-around.

Although I may vent because I won’t get to watch my favorite U.S. gymnast compete for the all-around title, I do not mean to be disrespectful in any way to the Olympics or the opposing Olympic gymnasts. Some people may be wondering the reason for the rule and I think Baron Pierre de Coubertin’s Olympic creed sums it up perfectly. It reads as follows:

“The most important thing in the Olympic Games is not to win but to take part, just as the most important thing in life is not the triumph but the struggle. The essential thing is not to have conquered but to have fought well.”

No comments:

Post a Comment